View Single Post
  #10  
Old 18-08-2010, 05:37 AM
nutron nutron is offline
Member
 
Join Date: Jan 2008
Posts: 53
Default Re: WI on IDI 1.9 Turbo Diesel

I found on mine that below 50% methanol I lost power aswell. Running 100% water seem clean up smoke though, which I did not expect from my research. Possibly because with the reduced cylinder temps, the unburn fuel doesn't carbonise as it would in the absense of oxygen in a normal heat cycle.

Methanol obviously burns hotter and faster than diesel and there is only a limited amount of oxygen available in the cyclinders as has been said. As you pump in more and more methanol, it will burn in preference to the diesel. This is because it burns faster and because you can burn twice as much methanol in the same amount of oxygen as you can diesel. So as the smoke increases from adding more methanol, it's the diesel that isn't burning on the whole that is producing the smoke, not the methanol.

The burn temp of diesel under atmospheric condictions is about 800 Deg C, where as Methanol burns around 1200 Deg C. As you increase the pressure, these burn temps increase and the thermal energy has to be disapated before the next burn or it will build up. In my experiments, I found that 70% methanol gave virtually the same if not slightly lower EGTs than just adding more diesel until I hit max power. So i would recomend you start at 50:50 and go no higher than 70:30 methanol:water mix. Getting the right mix for your engine will be trial and error using measuring equipment to avoid damage. methanol burns hotter and faster, water retards the auto ignition point because it cools the mix

I would retard the amount of diesel you are adding and add more water/methanol as you can get more torque for the same power this way. The water expanding into steam obviously creates alot more pressure than just heating the air in the cylinders. the amount you are injecting is tiny to be honnest. You are using american gallons per hour (gph) (American gallons too which are about 3.79ltr) nossels which are based on 100psi of relative pressure at the nossel into atmosphere pressure. Without testing the pump pressure and a graph from the supplier such as Aquamist can supply for their nossels, of flow over pressure for a given nossel; you have no way of knowing what amount of water you are actually delivering to the engine.

I currently inject about 1.135 ltrs per minute into my 1.9 common rail turbo diesel. That would be about 68.1 ltr/hour or 18gph to compare to your nossel markings. So I'm not supprised that you are seeing very little chages with your small nossels.

One thing I am interested by is the knock, as the auto ignition point of methanol is significantly higher than that of diesel (diesel = 210 C, methanol = 470 C). So in order for the methanol to be pre-igniting, you would have to have unthinkably high cylinder pressures, that would without a doubt be giving massive rises in EGTs if the engine was actually capable of withstanding them (which I find implausable at best). So I think you need to look to a different reason for this knocking sound, which may well be the methanol but not as you think. The specific heat capacity of water of massive, that's why we use it for cooling, fighting fires, e.c.t. Methanol however isn't as good and as though it would cool the intake charge, on it's own it could expand and create higher cylinder pressures and temps (this is only a theory). If you have a non-dirrect diesel injection with a pre-ignition chamber, the diesel might be igniting at the wrong point, or it might be igniting, and creating a sufficiently high temp to then ignite the methanol in the cylinder before the flame wall reaches it. With a direct injection engine, the fuel is injected at the point it is supposed to ignite and that would remove the possibility I would have though.

Knock occurs in a spark ignition engine when the pressure and temp are so high that you get compression ignition, independant of the spark. you can get pockets of fuel igniting beyond the flame wall, sending multiple flame walls across the cylinder, causing shock waves which you hear as knock. A diesel engine does this normally anyway.

Without knowing more about the sound, vibrations, boost, I don't think anyone can give sound advice on what your problem is. I would try reducing the amount of diesel, replacing it with a 50:50 mix of water:methanol, increasing the amount you inject and see how you go.
__________________
Vectra 1.9CDTI 235whp/380lbft (270bhp/405lbft) NOS+Methanol
Reply With Quote